CONDITION RATINGS
Rating three.
Read the why.
Understand condition rating 3, read the finding and recommended action, and decide what needs repair or investigation before you commit.
Red flags, read properlyChimney stacks
There is a single shared chimney stack at the ridge on each party line, both of coursed stone. The pointing to the left-hand stack is eroded to a depth of 15 to 20mm over much of its exposed height, and the cement flaunching around the pots is cracked and has lifted away from the pots on the weather side. The lead soakers and flashings at the stack base are visibly lifted along the front edge.
We recommend that a roofing contractor repoints both stacks in full, renews the flaunching, and re-dresses the flashings at the stack base. This should be done before you commit to the purchase, so that the cost and the extent of the work are known to you.
Condition rating 3 in the fictional Level 2 specimen: read the observed chimney defects alongside the recommended action before commitment.
The answer
A condition rating 3 does not automatically mean the house is structurally unsound or that you must withdraw.
Read the element’s findings, urgency and recommended action, then resolve the significant uncertainty before exchange.
The evidence
Read the words behind the number.
- 01
Identify the element
A roof defect, unsafe electrical installation and structural movement are different issues even if each receives the same rating. Do not treat every red entry as the same cost or level of purchase risk.
- 02
Read the recommendation
Check whether the report describes an observed defect, a safety concern or an important matter requiring further investigation. Ask the surveyor to explain any wording that leaves you unsure what action is actually required.
- 03
Separate cost from uncertainty
A clearly defined repair can be priced. A concealed defect with unknown extent may first need access, testing or specialist advice. A contractor’s broad allowance is not the same as evidence that the issue has been resolved.
- 04
Prioritise before exchange
Ask which matters should be investigated before legal commitment and which can form a planned maintenance budget. Discuss safety issues promptly and make sure your conveyancer sees relevant structural and documentation concerns.
Read the detail
Use the follow-up conversation.
Prepare a short list: what is the concern, what could happen if it is left, who should assess it, and what result would let you make a decision? Ask which findings interact, such as a leaking gutter and damp below it.
Do not negotiate by multiplying the number of red ratings by a guessed repair cost. Obtain appropriate evidence, allow for access and making good, and avoid double-counting work that remedies several linked symptoms.
Before you commit
Turn a rating into a decision.
- 01
Read the whole finding
Read the whole element entry, including limitations.
- 02
Clarify the recommendation
Discuss unclear actions with the reporting surveyor.
- 03
Obtain the specific evidence
Obtain the specific tests or quotations recommended.
- 04
Decide with the gaps understood
Agree your purchase decision with the outstanding evidence in view.
Scope and sources
Know what you are booking.
SurveyChoice arranges home surveys with a named independent practice. The practice provides the inspection and professional advice. Discuss known concerns, specialist requirements and access before accepting its terms.
Continue with Red flags, read properly for the next part of this decision.
Further reference: RICS: choosing a home survey (opens in a new tab). Requirements depend on the property, agreed scope and jurisdiction.
The decision rule
Choose the scope from the property and resolve significant unknowns before committing.
Help me choose a surveyQuestions
A few good
questions.
Talk to us 01Is a rating 3 a failed survey?
A home survey is not a pass-or-fail certificate. The rating directs attention to a serious or urgent defect or an important investigation, as explained in the report.
02Does the seller have to pay for every red item?
No automatic repair obligation arises from the colour of the rating. Your conveyancer can advise on the contract; price and repair arrangements are usually matters for negotiation.